The Commander Series Forum

Forum Home Forum Home
ImageCurrent Forum Category Blitzkrieg Commander, 1936-45
ImageImageCurrent Forum BKC Rule Queries
ImageImageImageCurrent Topic Calling in artillery
Post Reply
Post Reply
Author Page 1 
polar bear
United Kingdom
Joined 24/07/09
Last Visit 21/02/10
81 Posts
Posted on 07 November 2009 at 08:54:15 GMT
Hi Guys

1. Can an FAO call in artillery fire from units with different template sizes and deviations in the same order? And if so, how is the fire resolved?

2. Again, if it can do that, what would the command roll modifer be for calling in two gun units and two rocket units?

Many thanks

Polar Bear
pete
Wales
Joined 05/02/04
Last Visit 07/05/19
3793 Posts
Posted on 07 November 2009 at 11:30:23 GMT
1. Yes, you make separate deviation rolls

2. -2
polar bear
United Kingdom
Joined 24/07/09
Last Visit 21/02/10
81 Posts
Posted on 08 November 2009 at 05:48:16 GMT
Thanks Pete. Smile

A follow on question - when you make separate deviation rolls (in the above case or with, say, two aircraft units attacking) do you calculate all hits from both deviations before working out suppression or is suppresion checked for from each deviation separately?

Cheers

Polar Bear
pete
Wales
Joined 05/02/04
Last Visit 07/05/19
3793 Posts
Posted on 08 November 2009 at 13:34:26 GMT
Calculate each separately.
polar bear
United Kingdom
Joined 24/07/09
Last Visit 21/02/10
81 Posts
Posted on 08 November 2009 at 14:04:07 GMT
Thanks again. Smile
AJ at the bank
United Kingdom
Joined 23/09/07
Last Visit 14/06/24
335 Posts
Posted on 09 November 2009 at 12:57:59 GMT
Mmmm....
Thats interesting Pete.

Everything in the Command phase seems to require all attacks and suppression roles to be made at the same time when more than 1 unit attacks the same target. Obviously this is different for the Initiative phase.

In the Air Support phase rules clearly say that when multiple units are attacking the same target - test for each one seperately.

But in the Artillery phase dont you roll all the deviations...see where there is any overlap of fire zones....and roll all the attacks on units caught in the overlap together?

If not rolled all together....

This makes calling in and firing normal artillery units on the same order with rockets and naval guns VERY powerful. Where they overlap, you can get suppression and fall back in one order.

(1) Isn't the benefits of rockets/naval the bigger fire zone? Having a chance to get suppression & fall back on all artillery fired against the same target in one order seems a little tough. Usually you have to make another order roll to stand a chance of forcing a fall-back.

(2) For British players - does this mean they could call in 6 25pdr artillery units....decide that 3 units would be using a 20cm zone (and therefore adding 3 attacks into that fire zone) and also decide 3 units would be using a 30cm zone. They would then roll deviation for each group of units...and do each one seperately?

Can I get your clarification please?
Ta

Grin
pete
Wales
Joined 05/02/04
Last Visit 07/05/19
3793 Posts
Posted on 09 November 2009 at 15:01:48 GMT
Hmmm, that's the problem with having different versions of the game out (at least in my head the new book is out!). With BKC, you just double the deviation distance when rockets are firing, so ignore the point I made above.
Page 1