The Commander Series Forum

Forum Home Forum Home
ImageCurrent Forum Category Cold War Commander, 1946+
ImageImageCurrent Forum CWC Rule Queries
ImageImageImageCurrent Topic Opportunity Fire Clarification
Post Reply
Post Reply
Author Page 1 
StefanPKs
United Kingdom
Joined 07/08/07
Last Visit 24/10/12
220 Posts
Posted on 26 September 2009 at 13:47:34 GMT
This came up in a game between The Git (Steve) and Ryan last night: if a unit is mving and firing (stabilisers) and the opponent calls for opp fire and suppresses the unit can it fire because it was going to or not? We guessed not.
Panzerleader71
Canada
Joined 26/01/08
Last Visit 18/02/15
765 Posts
Posted on 26 September 2009 at 15:11:41 GMT
AFAIK if it was the unit moving that initiated the opp fire, and it was supressed by said fire, then the move stops and the unit is supressed from that point on. In other words they would not be able to fire in that turn.
StefanPKs
United Kingdom
Joined 07/08/07
Last Visit 24/10/12
220 Posts
Posted on 26 September 2009 at 15:29:15 GMT
Thats what we thought although it is not explicit in the book. I was referee for my sins!Stunned
stu_dew
United Kingdom
Joined 26/03/08
Last Visit 08/05/12
170 Posts
Posted on 26 September 2009 at 15:31:17 GMT
Stabilised vehicles can either “move up to half-distance, *then* fire or fire, *then* move up to half-distance” [my emphasis] (page 21 - Stabilisation). As both moving and firing provoke opportunity fire (again, page 21 – Opportunity Fire) there would be two chances for a given enemy unit to interrupt with opportunity fire - either after the firing or after the moving.

If a unit is suppressed by the opportunity fire provoked by the first ‘thing’ it did (either moving or firing) it wouldn’t get to do the second thing it had planned (firing or moving).

That’s how I play it anyways…
StefanPKs
United Kingdom
Joined 07/08/07
Last Visit 24/10/12
220 Posts
Posted on 26 September 2009 at 16:22:13 GMT
cool
Panzerleader71
Canada
Joined 26/01/08
Last Visit 18/02/15
765 Posts
Posted on 26 September 2009 at 16:29:19 GMT
This is not an opp fire question, but a stabilization one. to move and shoot in a turn does require two orders correct?
pete
Wales
Joined 05/02/04
Last Visit 07/05/19
3793 Posts
Posted on 26 September 2009 at 16:32:22 GMT
Stu is correct Wink
Serotonin
United Kingdom
Joined 19/03/08
Last Visit 16/02/13
84 Posts
Posted on 27 September 2009 at 01:23:48 GMT
I play it like Stu too.
Serotonin
United Kingdom
Joined 19/03/08
Last Visit 16/02/13
84 Posts
Posted on 27 September 2009 at 01:24:26 GMT
Panzer- shoot and scoot (as I call it) is 1 order if you have stabilisers.
julianmcdonnell
United Kingdom
Joined 16/05/07
Last Visit 05/09/14
20 Posts
Posted on 02 October 2011 at 16:27:48 GMT
Just want to check the FAO/FACs cannot call Opportunity Fire. Can't find specific reference in the book so we have assumed that Opp Fire only applies to 'manoeuvre' type forces e.g MBTs, IFVs, ATGW, Dismtd Inf etc and excludes Command Units and 'Off Table' assets.Huh?
nikharwood
Sea
Joined 14/08/05
Last Visit 08/11/22
1472 Posts
Posted on 02 October 2011 at 16:39:52 GMT
Yep - you're right there Julian; the statement in Opportunity Fire [p21] is that "All the rules for firing apply" - take this with the fact that Attack stats for commands "represent anti-aircraft fire" [p53] and are only therefore used in response to air support & there you have it.
julianmcdonnell
United Kingdom
Joined 16/05/07
Last Visit 05/09/14
20 Posts
Posted on 03 October 2011 at 09:45:53 GMT
Thanks Nik. JSmile
Page 1